High School

We appreciate your visit to What does it mean if a judge has a dissenting opinion A All judges unanimously vote against the law in question and deem it constitutional. This page offers clear insights and highlights the essential aspects of the topic. Our goal is to provide a helpful and engaging learning experience. Explore the content and find the answers you need!

What does it mean if a judge has a dissenting opinion?

A. All judges unanimously vote against the law in question and deem it constitutional.
B. None of the judges can come to an agreement on whether the law is unconstitutional.
C. A judge writes an opinion agreeing with the majority opinion and states why the ruling is correct.
D. A judge writes an opinion disagreeing with the majority opinion and states what the ruling should have been.

Answer :

if a judge has a dissenting opinion it means ' A judge writes an opinion disagreeing with the majority opinion and states what the ruling should have been.' The correct option is d.

A dissenting opinion in the legal context occurs when a judge or judges on a panel disagree with the majority's decision in a case. In this written opinion, the dissenting judge(s) articulate their disagreement with the ruling and often present an alternative interpretation of the law or a different legal rationale for the case's outcome.

This dissenting opinion is crucial to the legal system as it fosters transparency, encourages debate, and highlights differing legal perspectives. It allows for a comprehensive examination of the case and may influence future legal decisions or appeals, ensuring that the judiciary's decision making process is thorough and accountable to the principles of justice and the rule of law.

To learn more about rule of law, click here.

brainly.com/question/11463280

#SPJ4

Thanks for taking the time to read What does it mean if a judge has a dissenting opinion A All judges unanimously vote against the law in question and deem it constitutional. We hope the insights shared have been valuable and enhanced your understanding of the topic. Don�t hesitate to browse our website for more informative and engaging content!

Rewritten by : Barada